If you loved the movie 'First Cow', don't miss the docu 'Holly Cow': a journey through friendship and tradition

July 1, 2024

The Unlikely Friendship in "First Cow"


Let's begin with a movie that has nothing to do with cows but everything to do with friendship and entrepreneurship: 'First Cow', Directed by the master of quiet, contemplative cinema, Kelly Reichardt, this film is an exquisite meditation on the bonds formed between two unlikely companions in the 19th-century American frontier.


'First Cow' tells the story of Otis "Cookie" Figowitz, a skilled cook traveling with fur trappers in Oregon Territory. Cookie’s path crosses with King-Lu, a Chinese immigrant on the run from a group of Russians. This encounter sparks a friendship that is at the heart of the movie. Together, they embark on a culinary venture that hinges on one vital ingredient: milk from the first (and only) cow in the territory.


The film’s charm lies in its simplicity and the genuine bond between Cookie and King-Lu. Reichardt's direction is as subtle as ever, focusing on the quiet moments of connection and the gentle pace of frontier life. The two men’s scheme to steal milk from the titular cow to make "oily cakes" – a type of pastry – is both endearing and nerve-wracking. Their delicate operation and the subsequent success of their cakes at the local market illustrate a touching blend of ingenuity and desperation.


Reichardt’s film is a beautiful reminder of how friendship and mutual respect can thrive in the unlikeliest circumstances. The understated performances by John Magaro (Cookie) and Orion Lee (King-Lu) add depth and warmth to this tender narrative. As they navigate the harsh realities of their world, their friendship becomes a beacon of hope and resilience. In many ways, 'First Cow'  is a quiet revolution against the loud, action-packed narratives that often dominate Hollywood. It’s a docudrama in spirit, capturing the essence of a time and place with remarkable authenticity. It’s also a docuseries in potential, as one could imagine each episode delving deeper into the daily lives and challenges faced by Cookie and King-Lu.


But while 'First Cow'  offers a serene exploration of friendship and enterprise, 'Holy Cow' takes us on a more tumultuous journey into the heart of tradition and change in a small Azerbaijani village.


 The Cultural Clash in "Holy Cow"


Jumping across the globe, we find ourselves in the picturesque mountains of Azerbaijan with Imam Hasanov’s Holy Cow. This captivating documentary available on Guidedoc, follows Tapdiq, a man with a dream as big as his heart. Tapdiq’s mission is simple yet profoundly disruptive: he wants to bring a European cow to his conservative village. His choice to name the cow Madonna adds a delightful layer of humor to the tale.


'Holy Cow' is a gripping documentary, available here, that dives deep into the clash between modernity and tradition. Tapdiq believes that a European cow, with its superior milk production, will improve his family’s living conditions. However, his dream is met with suspicion and resistance from his fellow villagers. The older generation sees this foreign cow as a threat, convinced that its milk could bring disease and misfortune. Even Tapdiq’s wife, Vafa, is hesitant to embrace this strange new addition to their lives.


Hasanov’s documentary is not just about a cow; it’s about the human condition. It explores how people deal with change and how deeply rooted prejudices can be. The conservative community’s reaction to Madonna the Cow is a microcosm of larger societal issues. It questions how ready we are to welcome newcomers and new ideas into our lives.


Tapdiq’s journey is both humorous and poignant. His unwavering determination to bring Madonna into the village is met with a series of challenges, each reflecting the broader theme of resistance to change. The film captures these moments with a blend of humor and empathy, making it a compelling watch.


The documentary 'Holy Cow' is an intimate, unfiltered look at Tapdiq’s struggle. The observational style of the film immerses viewers in the village life, showcasing the beauty and simplicity of the Azerbaijani countryside. Hasanov’s direction is subtle, letting the story unfold naturally without unnecessary dramatization.


The villagers' skepticism towards Madonna is portrayed with a mix of comedy and drama. Their exaggerated fears about the cow’s milk are both amusing and telling of their deep-seated mistrust of anything foreign. This tension between the old and the new, the familiar and the unknown, is the crux of the film.


About the Documentary "Holy Cow" and Its Themes: 


  • Tapdiq's Dream: Tapdiq’s ambition to bring a European cow to his village symbolizes his hope for a better future. He sees Madonna not just as a cow but as a ticket to improved living conditions for his family. This dream sets the stage for the film’s exploration of change and progress.


  • Community Resistance: The villagers' resistance to Madonna represents a broader fear of change. Their mistrust of the foreign cow’s milk is a metaphor for their reluctance to embrace new ideas and ways of life. This theme is universal, resonating with audiences beyond the Azerbaijani context.


  • Family Dynamics: Tapdiq’s wife, Vafa, embodies the internal conflict faced by many in the village. Her initial reluctance to accept Madonna mirrors the broader societal hesitation. However, her gradual warming to the idea reflects the potential for change and adaptation within traditional frameworks.


  • Cultural Reflection: 'Holy Cow' is a reflection on how deeply ingrained traditions can influence perceptions and actions. The film questions the validity of these traditions in the face of modern challenges and opportunities. It prompts viewers to consider how they react to change in their own lives.


  • Universal Themes: While set in Azerbaijan, the themes of 'Holy Cow' are universal. The film’s exploration of tradition, progress, and the human response to change resonates with audiences worldwide. It highlights the commonalities in human experiences, regardless of geographical or cultural differences.


Two Tales of Friendship


Both 'First Cow' and 'Holy Cow' offer rich narratives that delve into human connections and the challenges of embracing change. While 'First Cow' uses the backdrop of the American frontier to explore a burgeoning friendship and the entrepreneurial spirit, 'Holy Cow' presents a contemporary tale of one man’s dream clashing with traditional values in a small Azerbaijani village.


These films, though vastly different in setting and style, share a common thread: they highlight the resilience and adaptability of the human spirit. They remind us that whether we are stealing milk to make oily cakes or introducing a foreign cow to improve our livelihood, the essence of our struggles and triumphs lies in our ability to navigate change and form meaningful connections along the way.


For those who enjoy thoughtful, well-crafted narratives, both 'First Cow' and 'Holy Cow' are must-watch films. They offer more than just entertainment; they provide insights into the human condition and the intricate dance between tradition and progress. So, the next time you find yourself scrolling through Netflix or Guidedoc, consider these gems. They might just change the way you see the world.


Watch more great documentaries on Guidedoc

Join GuideDoc